As a residential real estate agent with a deep appreciation for the Hamptons’ history and beauty, I’m excited to share some of the region’s most iconic sites. From charming historic buildings to striking modern architecture, the Hamptons is home to a rich blend of cultural heritage, design excellence, and natural beauty. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a longtime resident, these must-see destinations offer a glimpse into what makes this community so special

The Temple in Sag Harbor – Congregation Tifereth Israel
200 Brick Kiln Rd, Sag Harbor
The Congregation Tifereth Israel, also known as the Sag Harbor Temple, is the oldest continuously operating synagogue in the U.S., built in 1843. This Greek Revival building has been a central part of the Jewish community in the Hamptons for nearly 180 years and remains an important cultural landmark. Its Doric columns and serene atmosphere continue to serve as a center for Jewish worship and community activities.
www.sagharbortemple.org

Montauk Point Lighthouse
2000 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
No visit to Montauk is complete without a trip to the Montauk Point Lighthouse, New York’s oldest lighthouse. Standing proudly since 1796, this historical landmark has been guiding ships safely to shore for centuries. The lighthouse’s classic maritime architecture and sweeping views of the Atlantic Ocean make it an iconic Hamptons destination.
www.montauklighthouse.com

The Bridgehampton Museum – The Nathaniel Rogers House
2368 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton
The Nathaniel Rogers House is a beautifully restored example of Greek Revival architecture. Built in 1830, it serves as part of the Bridgehampton Museum, offering a fascinating look at the region’s agricultural and commercial development. The home’s historic charm and well-preserved features make it an essential stop for anyone interested in the Hamptons’ heritage.
www.bridgehamptonmuseum.org

The Bridgehampton Presbyterian Church
2429 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton
This Neo-Gothic church, completed in 1851, is a beautiful example of classic religious architecture. Known for its intricate stonework and stained-glass windows, the Bridgehampton Presbyterian Church is one of the most photographed landmarks in the Hamptons and a vital part of the community.
www.bridgehamptonchurch.org

The American Hotel
Located in the heart of Sag Harbor, the American Hotel has been offering hospitality since 1846. With its charming historic atmosphere, it’s a perfect example of Hamptons hospitality. This beautifully preserved hotel invites visitors to step back in time and experience the region’s rich history while enjoying modern comforts.
Address: 49 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
www.theamericanhotelsagharbor.com

Villa Maria
49 Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island
Villa Maria, built in 1912 and located on Shelter Island, is an architectural gem with its Mediterranean-style design. The mansion boasts stunning views of the surrounding landscape, making it one of the most beautiful estates in the area. This historical mansion is an excellent example of early 20th-century architecture in the Hamptons.
www.shelterisland.com

St. Andrew’s Dune Church
1 St. Andrews Rd, Southampton
Located on Dune Road in Southampton, this gothic-style church has been a cherished part of the community since 1879. Known for its shingle-style architecture and breathtaking ocean views, St. Andrew’s Dune Church is a peaceful and picturesque landmark that blends history and beauty.
www.standrewsdunechurch.org

Pollock-Krasner House
830 Springs-Fireplace Rd, East Hampton
For art lovers, the Pollock-Krasner House in East Hampton is a must-see. The former home and studio of abstract expressionist artists Jackson Pollock and Lee Krasner, this historic house is now a museum dedicated to their lives and work. Explore the preserved space where these artistic legends created their masterpieces.
www.stonybrook.edu/pkhouse

Mulford Farmhouse
10 James Ln, East Hampton
Built in 1680, the Mulford Farmhouse in East Hampton is one of the oldest surviving buildings in the region. This 17th-century farmhouse offers a glimpse into the area’s early agricultural history, showcasing traditional colonial architecture. The farmhouse is a must-see for those interested in Hamptons’ colonial history.
www.easthamptonhistory.org

Home Sweet Home Museum
14 James Ln, East Hampton
Another significant piece of East Hampton’s history is the Home Sweet Home Museum, built in 1680. This colonial-era home has been preserved as a museum, offering visitors a chance to step into the past and experience life during the 17th and 18th centuries. The museum is a hidden gem for anyone fascinated by the early history of the Hamptons.
www.easthamptonhistory.org

Guild Hall
158 Main St, East Hampton
Located in East Hampton, Guild Hall has been a cultural cornerstone since 1931. The museum hosts a variety of exhibitions and performances throughout the year, making it a key venue for art lovers and those interested in the region’s vibrant cultural scene.
www.guildhall.org

Moran Studio
16 North Main St, East Hampton
Once the workspace of renowned marine artist Robert M. Moran, the Moran Studio is a hidden gem in East Hampton. The studio has preserved its historic charm and remains a significant part of the area’s artistic heritage.
www.easthamptonhistory.org

East Hampton Library
159 Main St, East Hampton
East Hampton Library serves as a hub for knowledge and culture, offering a rich history and a variety of community programs. This landmark library has played a significant role in the intellectual life of the region for generations.
www.easthamptonlibrary.org

The Big Duck
20 Longneck Blvd, Flanders
A quirky and beloved roadside attraction, the Big Duck in Flanders has become an iconic symbol of the region’s agricultural past. Built in 1931, this giant duck-shaped structure was originally a duck farm and now serves as a landmark for visitors passing through the area.
www.bigduck.org

Discover the Timeless Charm of the Hamptons

The Hamptons offers a perfect blend of timeless charm and modern sophistication, with these landmarks embodying the best of both worlds. As someone who has witnessed the area’s evolution, I encourage you to explore these architectural gems to fully appreciate the beauty, history, and culture that define this special region. If you’re in the market for a home in the Hamptons, I’m here to guide you through the process, keeping both historical significance and modern luxury in mind.

---

Michele Mahl

THE AGENCY | Hamptons
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
License #: 40MA1154214
(917) 374-6456
Michele.Mahl@theagencyre.com