The Best Grocery Stores and Markets in the Hamptons
As a real estate agent in the Hamptons, I know that having access to high-quality groceries and fresh local ingredients is just as important as finding the perfect home. Whether you’re stocking your kitchen for a summer getaway or looking for the best farm-to-table ingredients year-round, this guide highlights the top grocery stores and markets in the Hamptons.
Southampton
Barryville General
A specialty market with curated grocery items, artisanal goods, and high-quality ingredients.
Visit Barryville General | 1 & 15 Hill St | (631) 204-3296
Citarella
A high-end gourmet market with premium meats, seafood, and prepared foods.
Visit Citarella Southampton | 20 Hampton Rd | (631) 283-6600
Clamman Seafood Market
Fresh seafood market offering daily catches and prepared seafood items.
Visit Clamman Seafood Market | 235A North Sea Rd | (631) 283-6669
Stop & Shop Grocery
A full-service supermarket offering a wide range of groceries and household essentials.
Visit Stop & Shop Grocery 167 Main St | (631) 283-0045
Village Cheese Shop
Specialty foods and sandwiches with a curated selection of artisanal cheeses.
Visit Village Cheese Shop | 11 S. Main St | (631) 283-6949
Water Mill
Milk Pail Fresh Market
Family-run farm stand offering fresh produce, prepared foods, cider, and baked goods.
Visit Milk Pail Fresh Market | 1346 Montauk Hwy | (631) 537-2565
Bridgehampton
Citarella
A high-end gourmet market with premium meats, seafood, and prepared foods.
Visit Citarella Bridgehampton | 2209 Montauk Hwy | (631) 283-6600
King Kullen
A full-service supermarket with a large selection of groceries and essentials.
Visit King Kullen | 2044 Montauk Hwy | (631) 537-2681
Round Swamp Farm
Known for its fresh-baked goods, homemade prepared foods, and farm-fresh produce.
Visit Round Swamp Farm | 97 School St | (631) 296-8078
Sagaponack
Loaves & Fishes
A renowned gourmet food store offering freshly prepared meals and specialty ingredients.
Visit Loaves & Fishes | 50 Sagg Main St | (631) 537-0555
Sag Harbor
Cavaniola’s Gourmet
Specialty cheese, wine, and gourmet prepared foods.
Visit Cavaniola’s Gourmet | 89 Division St | (631) 725-0095
Cromer’s Market
A classic butcher shop and grocery market offering fresh meats and prepared foods.
Visit Cromer’s Market | 3500 Noyac Rd | (631) 725-9004
Harbor Market & Kitchen
A gourmet market and café with high-quality ingredients and prepared foods.
Visit Harbor Market & Kitchen | 184 Division St | (631) 725-4433
Provisions
Organic market and café.
Visit Provisions | 7 Main St | (631) 725-3636
Schiavoni’s Market
A beloved local grocery store offering fresh produce, meats, and essentials.
Visit Schiavoni’s Market | 48 Main St | (631) 725-0366
Serene Green Farm
A farm stand specializing in local produce, seafood, and specialty items.
Visit Serene Green Farm | 3980 Noyac Road | (631) 808-3203
Wainscott
The Seafood Shop
A local favorite for fresh fish, shellfish, and seafood takeout.
Visit The Seafood Shop | 356 Montauk Hwy | (631) 537-0633
East Hampton
Citarella
A high-end gourmet market with premium meats, seafood, and prepared foods.
Visit Citarella East Hampton | 2 Pantigo Rd | (631) 283-6600
East Hampton IGA
A local staple for everyday grocery needs.
Visit East Hampton IGA | 92 N. Main St | (631) 324-0529
Round Swamp Farm
Offers local goods and a fantastic lineup of prepared foods
Visit Round Swamp Farm | 184 Three Mile Harbor | (631) 324-4438
Stop & Shop Grocery
A full-service supermarket offering a wide range of groceries and household essentials.
Visit Stop & Shop Grocery | 67 Newtown Lane | (631) 324-6215
Amagansett
Amber Waves Market
A community-supported farm, market, and café offering organic produce, baked goods, and local provisions.
Visit Amber Waves Market | 367 Main St | (631) 267-5664
Stuart’s Seafood Market
Fresh seafood and prepared foods.
Visit Stuart’s Seafood Market | 41 Oak Lane | (631) 267-6700
Montauk
Duryea’s Market
A high-end market offering fresh seafood, gourmet items, and specialty goods.
Visit Duryea’s Market | 65 Tuthill Road | (631) 668-2410
Herb’s Market
A local butcher and grocery store offering fresh meats and prepared foods.
Visit Herb’s Market | 778 Montauk Hwy | (631) 668-2335
Montauk IGA
A convenient supermarket for everyday essentials.
Visit Montauk IGA | 654 Montauk Hwy | (631) 668-4929
Farmers’ Markets | Fresh, Local, and Handcrafted Goods
No trip to the Hamptons is complete without visiting a farmers’ market, where you can find the best seasonal produce, artisanal foods, and handcrafted goods. The East End Farmers’ Market in Sag Harbor is a favorite, offering everything from fresh organic vegetables to handmade soaps and textiles.
These markets highlight the Hamptons’ farm-to-table culture, giving shoppers the chance to support local farmers and artisans while bringing home high-quality, locally sourced products.
Read More: The Best Hamptons Farm Stands
Finding the Best Markets for Every Culinary Need
No matter where you are in the Hamptons, there’s a grocery store or market that can provide top-quality ingredients and specialty items to elevate your meals. Whether you’re hosting a summer dinner party or just picking up everyday essentials, these local spots ensure you have access to fresh, delicious, and thoughtfully sourced products. Happy shopping!
For expert guidance in the Hamptons luxury real estate market, contact me today.
With over 20 years of experience and a deep knowledge of the local market, I offer personalized service whether you’re buying, selling, or seeking a Hamptons seasonal rental. Let’s schedule a consultation and explore the luxurious homes and properties that match your vision in the Hamptons.
Michele Mahl
THE AGENCY | Hamptons
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
License #: 40MA1154214
(917) 374-6456
Michele.Mahl@theagencyre.com
Social Cookies
Social Cookies are used to enable you to share pages and content you find interesting throughout the website through third-party social networking or other websites (including, potentially for advertising purposes related to social networking).